Clusters of unvaccinated kids create WNC health time bomb
Published on the Dec. 16, 2015 Carolina Public Press website
By Whitney L.J. Howell
In the middle of Western North Carolina sits one of the state’s most potentially dangerous time bombs. And, at any given moment, under the right circumstances, it could go off.
Despite North Carolina’s requirements that school-age children have up-to-date vaccinations before starting kindergarten, 5 percent of Buncombe County’s kindergarten population remained unvaccinated for the 2014-15 school year. Statistics for the 2015-16 school year are not yet available.
According to Dr. Jennifer Mullendore, medical director for Buncombe County Health & Human Services, the percentage is higher than previous years and is six times the state average.
With up to 20 percent of each of the county’s schools allowed to be unvaccinated, the possibility exists for a significant public-health crisis, she said.
“We’re holding our breath, waiting for an outbreak,” she said.
“We’re fortunate the measles outbreak in California (in April) didn’t make it here. Next time, we might not be that lucky.”
Exemptions
In North Carolina, a child can remain unvaccinated for two reasons: a medical exemption and a religious opt-out. Based on N.C. Department of Health & Human Services statistics, out of
Buncombe’s 2,488 kindergarteners, one has a medical exemption, including a waiver from a healthcare provider, and 125 opted out for religious reasons. Or at least that’s officially what they claim. The state does not offer a philosophical exemption, even though that’s exactly what some anti-vaccination groups in Buncombe Cuonty have advocated. It’s likely that not all “religious” waivers are faith-based.
Upon kindergarten enrollment, parents must present schools with their child’s official immunization record. Schools keep these records on file, including any medical or religious exemptions. Children without exemptions have 30 days to provide proof of immunization or they aren’t allowed to return to school.
In addition to Buncombe County, Polk County and Transylvania County round out top three WNC locales with the highest non-vaccinated rates, reporting 4.71 percent and 2.89 percent non-vaccinations, respectively.
Henderson County has the second highest total number of children without vaccinations — with one medical waiver and 14 religious exemptions. However, because this is a relatively large county for WNC, it’s rate is not especially out of the range seen in most counties across the state.
Elevated sickness
Although no widespread outbreaks have occurred, Buncombe frequently experiences a higher-than-average incidence of pertussis, also known as whooping cough, a highly contagious respiratory disease known for uncontrollable, violent coughing that makes it hard to breathe.
Despite being preventable with a vaccine, in 2014, Mullendore said, the county had 65 reported cases. Only Duplin County, a rural county near the coast known for its pig farms, had more with 138 cases.
There were 782 cases of whooping cough reported statewide in 2014.
But, knowing the reasons behind the high non-vaccination rate is difficult, Mullendore said.
“We suspect immunizations have done a great job keeping people healthy for 50-plus years, and people don’t have context for why immunizations are important,” Mullendore said.
“People who grew up in the 1960s had friends and family who died from diseases that we have vaccines for now. Younger people raising kids now never saw that, so we’ve lost that perspective.”
Immunizations for North Carolina’s children are free through the Vaccines for Children program, even for uninsured individuals. It’s possible, though, other factors that typically limit access to healthcare are also at play, including cultural or language barriers that make it difficult to take advantage of healthcare services, and, in this case, a low level of education about vaccines.
Tara Rybka, public health educator with the Transylvania County Public Health Department, said that although it’s never been directly connected to a lack of immunization, transportation difficulties frequently play a role in limiting access to healthcare services in counties like hers.
Herd sensitivity
In many cases, Mullendore said, parents research vaccines on their own, trusting potentially non-vetted, online sources rather than asking their pediatrician or other healthcare provider for information about possible risks and benefits associated with vaccinating their children. Some choose not to vaccinate based on their online findings, leaving the overall community more vulnerable to preventable disease.
Doing so is particularly dangerous, said Noel Brewer, associate professor of health behavior at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Gillings School of Global Public Health.
Vaccines provide herd immunity, he said, protecting the vaccinated and sheltering those who can’t receive vaccines due to conditions that compromise their immune systems, such as cancer.
On the flip side, however, non-vaccination can also create herd sensitivity, a phenomenon that gives rise to more severe cases of disease as individuals get sick at older ages.
Since most people are vaccinated, the risk of herd sensitivity might not seem too bad. But Brewer said this perception is misleading.
“Herd sensitivity is worse than people think,” he said. “Birds of a feather flock together, so those who are unvaccinated tend to stay together. But, you never have a pocket where 95 percent of people are vaccinated. It’s usually spread out to 80 percent or it can fall to 50 percent. These are the places that are vulnerable to outbreak and the spread of disease.”
Vaccination foes
Even with the risks of non-vaccination publicized throughout the healthcare community, Buncombe County has a relatively active anti-vaccine cohort, including Moms Against Mercury.
Based in Leicester, this organization, which did not return calls for comment, publicizes and supports the belief that mercury present in vaccines adversely affects the nervous system.
In recent years, the group has held six rallies, lobbying against the use of vaccines in their current forms.
According to the Centers for Disease Control & Prevention (CDC), though, the type of mercury used in vaccines – ethylmercury – is metabolized and cleared from the body far faster than the type of mercury – methylmercury – present in some types of fish. Consequently, CDC data states, ethylmercury is far less likely to be harmful.
Educating the public
County health officials are working to combat anti-vaccine efforts, Mullendore said. Last year, the Department of Health & Human Services worked with healthcare and childcare providers to expand educational services around the facts and benefits of vaccinating children.
Rather than targeting staunch anti-vaccine proponents who tend to dig their heels in when faced with information that contradicts their beliefs, health officials are reaching out through public forums to parents who are curious about vaccines. The effort could ultimately influence those who are on the fence about whether to vaccinate to proceed with immunizations.
Jennifer Garrett, director of nursing with Macon County Public Health also suggested holding school-based vaccination clinics to reach students who aren’t yet vaccinated. Macon’s health officials also reach out via phone to non-compliant parents to set up appointments for children to be vaccinated.
Ultimately, though, UNC’s Brewer said, the onus is on parents in communities with unvaccinated children to take steps that will side-step exposure to preventable disease. When children are sick, keep them home from school, he said, and know which pediatricians still choose to treat children who don’t have current vaccinations.
And, Brewer added, public health officials should continue to push for more widespread vaccinations.
“Getting information into the hands of those who are vaccinated can be helpful,” he said.
“More information needs to come from educators and physicians in the community. Not everyone will want to vaccinate, but more people are open to it than we currently believe.”
To read the story at its original location: http://www.carolinapublicpress.org/23894/clusters-of-unvaccinated-kids-create-wnc-health-time-bomb
Not Too Early or Too Late, Potty Training Timing Needs to Be Just Right
Published on the Nov. 12, 2014, North Carolina Health news website
New research on the timing of potty training shows problems for pushing children too soon or waiting too long.
By Whitney L.J. Howell
The frustrating journey of toilet training a child is a struggle every parent faces. Starting kids down this path early can be tempting, but a new study from Wake Forest University found that pushing the topic too soon – or too late – can cause physical problems and lead to wetting accidents.
Children who are toilet trained prior to age 2 or after age 3 have significantly more daytime and nighttime accidents than children trained between the two ages, the study showed.
“Toilet training seems like a religious topic,” said study leader Steve Hodges, a pediatric urologist at Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center. “People can get so mad and say they trained their child at age 2 or 1, and [that] everything is fine. But training too early or late is a risk factor, and we want to prevent toileting problems in all kids with maximal effect.”
As long as a child stays in diapers, his or her bladder continues to grow in size. Being able to urinate freely increases the bladder’s fluid capacity and actually helps it learn to function more effectively, he said. Once toilet training is introduced though, that growth stops. So, according to research from the University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, children who toilet train earlier will automatically have smaller bladders, potentially setting them up for future toileting problems.
But the real culprit behind wetting accidents, Hodges said, is constipation. Increased fullness in the bowels presses on the bladder, making it harder for children to control the flow of urine. Over longer periods, that same fullness can also stunt the bladder’s growth, further inhibiting capacity. In addition, the muscles used to restrict bowel movements are connected to muscles that control urination; constriction can make it harder for children to learn proper toileting behaviors.
This study is the first research to connect constipation to wetting accidents in younger children.
“Across the board, most voiding complaints in kids are due to incompletely emptying the colon, not anything to do with the bladder,” Hodges said. “There’s nothing inherently bad about pooping rarely as long as everything leaves the colon. It’s when the colon doesn’t empty that we start to see bladder problems, such as daytime wetting and urinary frequency.”
In some cases, constipation occurs when a child resists parents’ efforts to introduce toilet training. Other times, outside influences, such as a new sibling, can stall a child’s progress.
Hodges’ team followed the toileting habits of 112 children aged 3 to 10 for six months. The majority were toilet trained between ages 2 and 3, and parents reported 38 percent had a history of constipation and 45 percent had experienced daytime wetting.
Although anecdotal evidence shows girls can toilet train earlier and easier than boys, Hodges’ research found being male didn’t increase the likelihood of constipation or daytime wetting.
According to the findings, the children who toilet trained before age 2 were more than three times as likely to suffer from constipation than children who trained between ages 2 and 3. Children who trained after age 3 experienced constipation seven times as often. In addition, when compared to other children, kids who trained early and late had daytime wetness nearly four times and five times as often, respectively.
These problems can frequently be overlooked, said Triangle Center for Behavioral Health clinical psychologist Rebecca Dingfelder, because parents aren’t comfortable broaching the subject with their child’s physician. Dingfelder has expertise in working with children who have toilet-training difficulties.
“A lot of problems stem from parents being embarrassed to talk with pediatricians – not about toilet training but about the constipation that might be going on,” she said. “Parents need to discuss with their pediatricians how things are going with pooping, especially if there are problems with wetting the bed or wetting at school.”
It’s important to remember, Dingfelder said, that children develop at their own paces. Currently, the N.C. Department of Health & Human Services – the agency that oversees day-care center licensures in the state – doesn’t require that children be toilet trained by a certain age in day-care or pre-school environments. However, many such facilities maintain a policy that children must be fully trained before progressing to a 3-year-old classroom.
In some cases, she said, that mandate puts unrealistic expectations on the child and family.
“If a child is cognitively and socially ready to move on, and if toileting is the only thing getting in the way, then day-cares need to cooperate with families to see how they can make it work,” she said.
For example, if day-care facilities don’t have a changing table in the older classes, then arrangements could be made for the child to return to the younger class for diaper changes.
Ultimately, Dingfelder said, she hopes Hodges’ research will relieve much of the stress and anxiety parents feel around toilet training their children as soon as possible. Toilet training isn’t a race to the finish line, she said, and parents shouldn’t feel pressure to push their toddlers too soon.
“Parents these days will say, ‘My kid will read when they read and ride a bike when they ride,’” she said. “We need the same acceptance for toilet training – that it’s OK to start later, and that it’s OK to talk about the stumbling blocks along the way.”
To read the article at its original location: http://www.northcarolinahealthnews.org/2014/11/12/not-too-early-or-too-late-potty-training-timing-needs-to-be-just-right/
Medical Schools Get Creative With Child Care Benefits
Published in the December 2011 AAMC Reporter
By Whitney L.J Howell
As a surgeon, Robert Feezor, M.D., never expected he would eat earthworms at work. But as a father, he was thrilled to have the chance.
“It was Father’s Day, and they gave the dads earthworm ice cream,” said Feezor, assistant professor of vascular surgery at the University of Florida College of Medicine. “Basically, it was gummy worms in brownies, so it looked like earthworms in dirt. My son loved giving it to me.”
The treat came courtesy of Baby Gator, the medical center’s on-site day care facility where Feezor sends his three children—ages 5, 3, and 2—daily for a “stimulating educational child care experience.”
Accessible child care is one of the things that can add to the workplace attractiveness of an academic medical center. Baby Gator opened its on-site facility two years ago, joining other academic medical centers that have offered the same benefit—some for as long as 50 years. Many, including Yale and Stanford universities, have housed child care near hospitals and clinics for decades.
According to Sarah Bunton, Ph.D., AAMC research director of organization and management studies, longer hours of operation, close proximity to the hospital or clinic, and the possibility to see a child during the day make on-site day care a priority for faculty—both male and female.
“A dramatic change in the desire for on-site day care has been the increased number of fathers who want to be more involved with arranging care for their kids,” she said. “Through anecdotal reports from faculty affairs administrators and focus groups with select groups of faculty, more male faculty are also asking about and lobbying for this benefit.”
Baby Gator Director Pamela Pallas, Ph.D., said it was the medical school’s dean who first requested a location closer to the hospital.
“The dean called to tell me that top-notch residents were turning him down because he couldn’t guarantee he could offer appropriate child care,” Pallas said. “He was shocked child care was a deal breaker, but he wanted to know how we could get a Baby Gator close to the health sciences center.”
Within six months of opening, Pallas said, the center was at full capacity with112 children. There is now a waiting list 200 children long.
On-site child care is so popular, and the need for quality services so great, that parents scramble to put their children on waiting lists before birth. Some even make the attempt before conception. Jane Grady, Ph.D., associate vice president for human resources at Rush University Medical Center, once had a faculty member contact her upon getting engaged to ask if it was too early to put a yet-to-be-conceived child on the waiting list.
While the question amused Grady, who served as the first director of Rush’s Laurance Armour Day School, she was not surprised. Day care facilities at academic medical centers are more likely than other child care centers to have an educationally focused curriculum, making them a good choice for parents who already value extensive academic training, she said. Facilities on medical center campuses are also more likely to have highly educated staff.
“All our teachers have master’s degrees in early childhood education,” she said. “They are here to help the kids learn and have fun. We want to make sure they are well prepared for school at the same time we provide the excellent care the parents are looking for.”
During the 2008 presidential election, Feezor’s children learned about the various candidates and flags from different countries. When they learned about gardening, his 3-year-old enjoyed showing off the watermelon every time Feezor picked him up on the playground.
From the faculty perspective, paying for medical center-connected on-site day care can be easier than paying a center in the community, Grady said. Faculty can often choose from payroll deduction, using their health savings accounts, or monthly check.
Although these centers are coveted and provide an appreciated benefit to faculty, starting a day care facility is not always simple, said Phillips Kerr, director of compensations and benefits for the University of Massachusetts Medical Center-Worchester, which opened its facility in August 2010. The biggest stumbling block is finding an adequately sized space, as well as the funds to complete renovations, hire staff, and purchase necessary resources. In fact, he said, the best option could be outsourcing the day care’s administration.
“Fortunately, the university owned the space we used for the school,” Kerr said. “But rather than build everything from the ground up, the university decided to partner with an existing company to run the school. It’s been a positive experience.”
To read the article at its original location: https://www.aamc.org/newsroom/reporter/december2011/268878/childcare.html
A healthy start to life
Published in the Fall 2010 UNC-Chapel Hill Gilling School of Global Public Health Alumni Magazine: Carolina Public Health
By Whitney L.J. Howell
For 30 years, the number of overweight children has crept higher and higher. In 2008, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported 10 percent of children ages 2 to 5 had an unhealthy body mass index. Those children have a 70 percent chance of being overweight or obese adults.
Establishing good health habits early can reverse this trend and help children have healthy lives. The UNC Gillings School of Global Public Health leads the fight against the obesity epidemic and promotes healthy behaviors locally, nationally and globally.
“Combating obesity is a key strategic area for the School,” says Peggy Bentley, PhD, nutrition professor and the School’s associate dean for global health. “UNC is playing a major role in obesity research. We have faculty and graduate student expertise from the molecular level through epidemiology, economics, interventions and policy.”
You are what your mother eats
Society’s advice to expectant mothers historically has been to “eat for two.” However, contemporary research shows that eating unhealthy, high-calorie foods during pregnancycan put children at risk for weight struggles and health complications before they are born.
For 15 years, Anna Maria Siega-Riz, PhD, RD, nutrition and epidemiology professor and associate dean for academic affairs at the School, has analyzed prenatal nutrition data to determine which health habits give children the best start in life.
“Pregnancy is a happy moment in life, but it’s also when women are most concerned about the health of their child,” she says. “If they have bad health habits, many women are more likely to modify their behavior, at least in the short term.”
Although most women know to limit weight gain during pregnancy, 60 percent still gain more weight than they should, based on Institute of Medicine recommendations.(Siega-Riz was a member of the prestigious IOM panel that developed those guidelines, available at http://tinyurl.com/iom-guidelines.) Fewer than 25 percent receive guidance from their doctors about physical activity. Making and maintaining behavioral changes is difficult unless women have positive, consistent support.
Siega-Riz’s team uses the Internet, podcasts, chat rooms and cell phones to provide health information and online support for pregnant women. One podcast includes a skit in which four women, all at different parenthood stages, advise an expectant mom about choosing nutritious foods.
Women with healthy habits may avoid having a baby who is too large for gestational age (often leading to C-section births), prevent shoulder dystocia for the baby during birth, and limit the child’s risk for developing diabetes and obesity.
“Women who aren’t eating right or exercising need assistance,” Siega-Riz says. “We must help them find balance and give them all the support they require.”
Choosing healthful foods during pregnancy could reduce the burden of chronic diseases later in life, says Mihai Niculescu, MD, PhD, nutrition assistant professor. Whether the “fat gene” exists is debatable (see page 14), but Niculescu’s epigenetic work – research that determines how outside influences alter our DNA – shows that high-fat diets and maternal obesity in mice alter DNA, shutting down some genes and accelerating others. Developmental brain delays in offspring are the result.
When maternal obesity exists, the neurons in mouse fetal brains at 17 days of pregnancy appear less developed, according to Niculescu’s observations. The implications are worrisome, he says, because the effects are evident after three or four generations.
“This may have profound consequences for an offspring’s life, including his or her mental development and ability to learn,” he says. “A high-fat, less nutritious diet can also create food preferences in unborn offspring that lead them to choose unhealthy foods later in life.”
Open the hangar –here comes the airplane!
Parental influence over children’s nutrition doesn’t end at birth, but little research exists on

Karina Agopian, research assistant at UNC’s Nutrition Research Institute in Kannapolis, works with a toddler to determine what and how much the child has eaten. Research shows that early eating habits influence later food preferences and health outcomes.
what increases obesity risk in children under two. In 2002, Associate Dean Bentley became a pioneer in this area when she launched “Infant Care, Feeding and Risk of Obesity,” a study of strategies used by first-time African-American mothers to feed their 3-month to 18-month-old children.
With National Institutes of Health funding, Bentley recruited 217 mother-child pairs in North Carolina through the Women, Infants and Children program and videotaped them at three-month intervals to identify feeding styles. She and her team identified five styles: controlling, laissez-faire, responsive, pressuring and restrictive. Responsive mothers, she says, are “perfect moms” who pay close attention to and correctly interpret child cues of hunger and satiety. They are very engaged during feeding and may provide verbal and physical encouragement and help, when needed. Other styles pressure or even force children to eat when they reject food or overly restrict the quality and quantity of what children eat, often because the mother is concerned about her child becoming fat.
“Many factors play a role in how we feed infants. However, we believe that it is not just what children are fed, but also how they are fed that makes a difference in the child’s acceptance of food and perhaps in later food preferences and health outcomes,” Bentleysays. “Understanding the role these styles play in growth and development outcome sis a big part of what drives our childhood obesity study.”
Meghan Slining, PhD, nutrition assistant professor, analyzed data from Bentley’s study while she was a UNC doctoral student. Overweight infants – those who measured greater than the 90th percentile for weight versus length – were nearly twice as likely as normal-weight infants to have delayed motor development, Slining found.
“While baby fat may be cute,” Slining says, “it increases the chance that a child could become an overweight adult. We also have seen more immediate consequences to extra pudginess. These children have lower gross motor development.” (See a video about Slining’s research at http://tinyurl.com/slining-baby_fat.)
Add a mother with an eating disorder to the mix, and feeding a child becomes even more complex. Jordan Distinguished Professor of Eating Disorders Cynthia Bulik, PhD, used data from the Norwegian Mother and Child Cohort Study, which followed more than 100,000 Norwegian mothers, some of whom had anorexia or bulimia nervosa or binge-eating disorder, to determine how they fed their children. Bulik followed the mothers from 17 weeks’ gestation through their children’s eighth birthdays.
Although some mothers with eating disorders experienced a reprieve from their conditions during pregnancy, this was not universally the case. In fact, a surprising number of women developed binge-eating disorder during pregnancy. Eating disorders during pregnancy expose babies to erratic eating, Bulik says.
“The impact of roller-coaster caloric intake certainly affects growth and development,” Bulik says. “It could also affect obesity and diabetes risk, as well as the weight trajectory for later in life.”
Mothers with eating disorders also abandoned breastfeeding earlier than did healthy mothers, Bulik says. After giving birth,women with eating disorders often feel they no longer “have a reason to be overweight” and choose not to consume adequate calories to support breastfeeding. Bulik’s study also shows that, as these children grow, they are more likely to develop eating problems, such as having stomachaches, vomiting without cause or not enjoying food.
According to Miriam Labbok, MD, Professor of the Practice of maternal and child health and director of the School’s Carolina Global Breastfeeding Institute, a breastfeeding baby will “stop when full,” but bottlefeeding can overpower a baby’s ability to recognize satiety. When a parent insists that the baby empty the bottle, the child learns the habit of overeating, Labbok says. Additionally, breastfed babies are exposed to the tastes of foods eaten by their mothers. For a formula-fed child, food flavors are new and strange, which could cause the child to be a picky eater.
Employing research to instill good eating habits early is paramount to changing the course of human health, Bentley says.
“It’s harder to intervene and prevent nutrition problems when a child is older. They have preferences and eating patterns that make changes more complicated and difficult,” she says. “But, with the research ongoing at the School, we know we’re leading a positive trajectory of implementing healthy habits early.”
To read the story online: http://www.sph.unc.edu/images/stories/news/cph_2010_fall/documents/a_healthy_start.pdf
Babies tainted by many toxins, report says
Published in the April 12, 2010 Raleigh News & Observer & Charlotte Observer
DURHAM — Surprising as it may seem, the umbilical cord blood of babies born today can have traces of industrial chemicals that were banned 30 years ago, a report says. Their bodies can absorb at least 287 toxic chemicals while they are still in the womb.
Ken Cook is president and co-founder of Environmental Working Group, a nonprofit research and advocacy group. He was in North Carolina last week and discussed results of blood tests his organization conducted in 2004 on 10 American babies.
According to Cook, the EWG test is the first to look at how chemicals used in everyday life affect fetuses, and it shows

Ken Cook, president and co-founder of Environmental Working Group, presented environmental toxins research at Duke University in early April.
that industrial pollution begins in the womb.
Although these substances are present in the blood in minute levels, no research exists, he said, to show even small amounts aren’t dangerous.
“Babies should not be born pre-contaminated,” Cook said. “We must encourage our government to draft policies that require closer looks at the safety of these chemicals. We all need to be held accountable for fixing a broken [environmental health and safety] system.”
Cook presented his findings in a lecture co-sponsored by Duke University’s Nicholas School of the Environment and Earth Sciences and the Comprehensive Cancer Center. The partnership brings together researchers to study links between environmental pollution and public health.
The EWG test identified 212 chemicals and pesticides, including DDT; 28 waste byproducts produced by incinerators; and 47 other substances found in products containing nonstick surfaces such as Teflon or stain shields such as Scotchgard. Many contaminants are known carcinogens, are associated with birth defects, or can negatively affect hormones, Cook said.
Rebecca Fry, an assistant professor in environmental sciences and engineering at UNC Chapel Hill, said the EWG’s study is an important first step, and it calls for larger studies to establish the relationship between environmental contaminants in newborn blood and health outcomes.
“Just because we can measure a chemical in our blood doesn’t necessarily mean there will be a negative health outcome,” Fry said. “It is essential that the government become a partner to foster more extensive research.”
It is known that certain environmental contaminants contribute to problems such as low birth weight.
Christina McConnell, who is 24 weeks pregnant and has an 18-month-old son, said she was shocked by the number of chemicals found in cord blood and was concerned there is no foolproof way to avoid passing harmful chemicals to her unborn child.
“It’s surprising that some of these chemicals could have a big impact even in such small amounts,” she said.
“It’s sad that we can’t protect our families just by changing what we buy or eat and that we have to rely on the government to pass new policies.”
http://www.newsobserver.com/2010/04/12/433034/babies-tainted-by-many-toxins.html#ixzz0kswB4306 or http://www.charlotteobserver.com/2010/04/12/1371154/babies-tainted-by-many-toxins.html
Pediatricians Becoming Scarce in Select Areas
Published in the November 2004 AAMC Reporter
When Cheryl Pflueger’s contractions started four months before her due date, she traveled from her home in Brookings, S.D., to the Sioux Valley Children’s Hospital in Sioux Falls for preemptive steps that could halt early labor. The measures did not work, and Pflueger’s son Ben was born 16 weeks early, weighing 1 pound, 10 ounces.
Doctors immediately put Ben on a respirator designed specifically for the smallest infants, and Pfleuger and Sioux Falls special equipment for premature babies and pediatric specialists saved her son’s life.
“I have no doubt that if he’d been born in Brookings, he would not be here,” she said. “At the time he was born, we only had one pediatrician in Brookings.”
For the next three years, Pflueger, her 2-year-old daughter and Ben drove the one-hour trek between their hometown of 15,000 people and Sioux Falls many times for Ben’s follow-up appointments with eye doctors, hearing specialists and physical therapists. Pflueger’s husband often could not take time away from work, so the family was frequently separated. Traveling for medical treatment created a financial burden, as well.
“It would be great if we had these pediatricians within a short distance so all babies could get the best follow-up care,” Pflueger said. “It’s tough on some parents with the expense of driving, possibly staying overnight and then paying the bills for the doctors and specialists.”
Thousands of parents face similar problems each year when searching for healthcare for their children simply because they choose to live in less populated areas of the United States. The supply of general pediatricians is adequate and even growing in some parts of the country, according to several reports, but rural locations suffer from a scarcity of pediatric sub-specialists. And the problem is mounting.
Growing Without Spreading
From 1978 to 2000, the pediatrician population ballooned by 140 percent, according to a recent study by Gary Freed, M.D., a professor at the University of Michigan School of Public Health. This increase means the number of pediatricians per 100,000 children more than doubled from 49.8 to 106.2 during the period. These doctors, however, are not spread evenly nationwide.
“There is a significant difference in distribution of pediatricians across the country,” said Dr. Freed, who is also director of Michigan’s division of pediatrics. “This is not too say children don’t received healthcare from primary physicians, but this uneven distribution of pediatricians doesn’t provide parents with the choice of whether their kids can receive care from a pediatric sub-specialist.”
Family practitioners often step in to fill th void left by a less robust pediatrician population in smaller cities.
According to the study which was published in Pediatrics, pediatricians flock to more populated states, leading to high pediatrician-to-child ratios in select areas. For example, Massachusetts and New York have 165 and 154 pediatricians per 100,000 children, respectively. Inversely, South Dakota, Wyoming and Idaho have the fewest number of pediatricians per 100,000 children with 41, 35 and 28, respectively.
Visits to pediatric sub-specialists jumped substantially, as well. Children visit pediatricians for roughly 4.5 percent of their appointments, an increase of 2.9 percent since 1980.
Strategic Locations
The promise of higher income, more professional opportunities and increased social interactions drive pediatricians to settle in highly populated states. Dr. Freed said., leaving other states with a fraction of the physician workforce needed to effectively treat children. However, there is no data showing where pediatricians choose to locate.
The shortage is often a result of uneven geography of pediatric education in medical schools. Between 10 percent and 15 percent of medical school graduates each year pursue pediatric residencies, but not all states offer programs in the field. For example, the University of South Dakota School of Medicine does not have a pediatric residency, prompting, on aver, five to seven of its 50 students to leave the state each year, according to Lawrence Fenton, M.D., chair of South Dakota’s pediatrics department. Most graduates do not return after completing their residencies, but individuals who do are often general pediatricians.
“The challenge isn’t the general pediatrics, it’s the pediatric sub-specialties,” Dr. Fenton said. “Our sub-specialty care needs are huge. We’re the only tertiary care center for 250 miles, and it’s important that we serve the needs of all children in our patient area.”
Although South Dakota currently has 22 faculty members trained in various pediatric sub-specialty areas, between 15 percent and 20 percent will retire within the next decade. It will be difficult for South Dakota to entice younger specialists to come to a rural location when there is a desperate need for their services nationwide, Dr. Fenton said.
Michael Anderson, M.D., chairman of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) workforce committee, agreed. Despite the growing pediatric sub-specialist population, such doctors are likely to remain within or close to academic medical centers because that is where they receive their core support. This concentration is a roadblock to easy healthcare access and only exacerbates the shortage problem in rural areas.
“For families who live in less populated areas, the fact that sub-specialties aren’t around can be devastating,” Dr. Anderson said. “Families in underserved areas are at a significant disadvantage because it is difficult to coordinate the amount of services some children need.”
Because of the shortages, some children go without medical attention, Dr. Fenton said, and this problem because visible when a sub-specialist finally moves into town and is immediately swamped with patients.
Recruiting Difficulties
Attracting new pediatricians, especially sub-specialists, to smaller areas could continue to be a struggle, though, said Richard Pan, M.D., MPH, associate residency director of pediatrics for the University of California, Davis. Pediatric students find residency positions mostly at larger medical schools in urban areas, and approximately 40 percent stay in the area to practice. Salary is also a factor, Dr. Pan said, noting that pediatricians’ already low compensation makes moving to rural, less affluent locations even more unappealing.
Other lifestyle factors contribute to the decision to stay in larger cities. Many residents consider their spouse’s career options, whether their children will receive a quality education in smaller city and the question of how a heavier workload due to fewer colleagues might affect their schedules.
“Residents view this decision as a serious and significant issue with regard to lifestyle,” Dr. Pan said. “These are personal decisions that guide their career decisions.”
Marianne Felice, M.D., chair of pediatrics at the University of Massachusetts Medical School, echoed Dr. Pan’s thoughts, noting only a select few doctors can sustain the stress of being perpetually on-call because no other pediatricians are in town. Higher salaries and insurance reimbursement rates in large regions help to cover medical school debt, as well.
However, Dr. Felice pointed out that it is likely that not all pediatricians counted in Dr. Freed’s study are currently treating many patients. Although they are all licensed physicians, some could be faculty members or researchers, thereby lowering the actual pediatrician-to-child ratio in Massachusetts and other states with a large supply of pediatricians.
According to Scott Shipman, M.D., assistant professor of pediatrics at Oregon Health & Sciences University School of Medicine, budding pediatricians could have difficulty finding the job hey want in a larger city. The higher concentration means they may find themselves competing for a position they would not normally consider.
“There’s significant evidence in pediatrics to show there are fewer jobs available in populated areas,” Dr. Shipman said. “New graduates make sacrifices to stay where they are. They might be working weird hours or where they may not eventually settle down to practice.”
Offering Incentives
There are, however, measures the medical community can employ to i,prove the supply of general pediatricians and sub-specialists in rural locations. Even though it is unlikely that scores of these physicians will choose to relocate in the next few years, medial treatment can still reach children through telemedicine, said AAP expert Dr. Anderson. Not all services will be available through this method, but it could alleviate part of the problem.
Dr. Anderson said additional incentives are needed to entice new pediatricians to forgo a more affluent socially active lifestyle and practice in smaller locations. To draw more physicians in, hospitals could offer to pay off medical school debt if the pediatrician moves into the area.
Just as medical schools contribute to the uneven geographic distribution of pediatricians by virtue of their location, the schools can also help turn the tide to increase sub-specialist supply in the more rural areas across the country, according to Dr. Pan. Discussing the needs of underserved communities and encouraging students to practice there is not enough to improve rural medical care. Medical schools must consider this issue at the admissions phase.
“Medical schools need to look at who they are admitting overall,” Dr. Pan said. “It would be preferable to admit people from underserved or rural communities initially because they are more likely to go back there because they’ve lived there, know it and like it.”
Movie Review: Elf — Recapturing the Christmas Spirit
Published in the December 2003 AAMC Courier
For the past 10 years, at least, I’ve been going to the theaters during the holiday season, hoping to see a movie that recaptures the Christmas spirit I saw in films when I was a child. Needless to say, I’ve had none such luck. Lately, it seems that Hollywood no longer views Christmas as a time of good-natured cheer and family togetherness.
Although I’ve thoroughly enjoyed both Harry Potter and both Lord of the Rings movies (as have many of you) they just don’t fit into the mold of what I grew up expecting from a holiday-time movie. But, this year is different. This year, I met Buddy.
Buddy, played by former Saturday Night Live cast member Will Ferrell, is the central character of director Jon Favreau’s latest movie Elf. As an orphan who mistakenly climbs into Santa’s toy sack years ago, Buddy grows up in the North Pole, and despite his enormous size for an elf, epitomizes the warmth and good-cheer we expect from Santa’s little helpers.
Perhaps best known for his striking impressions of President George W. Bush or his antics as Craig, the awkward, sweaty Spartan cheerleader, Ferrell manages to portray a beautiful child-lie innocence as his character travels via iceberg to New York City in search of hi birth father, Walter, played by James Caan. Caan is also well cast as a hardened book publicist, neglectful of his other young son Michael and none-too-thrilled with the prospect of bringing the “elf” he never knew existed into his life.
At first glance, you may roll your eyes and groan, thinking this is another sappy, syrupy-sweet flick (though Buddy puts syrup on everything — including spaghetti) that runs the formula for a warn-hearted Christmas movie into the ground. But, it’s just not so. Ferrell’s grown-up spin on childish humor and the fact that we’re not left to languish on any sentimental moments sweeps both you and the movie along.
Overall, though, the main draw of Elf is its child-friendly qualities. Though some mild crude language is interspersed in the dialogue and some toilet humor is included, the “offenses” are so minor that they almost slip right by you without even being noticed. Of course, if you have small children, you might want to think about for how many days they would find a very long, loud belch hysterical.
The humor in this movie is simple. Buddy has never been in human society before, so he’s astounded by everything — cars, the tall buildings, revolving doors and even a coffee shop’s claim that it serves the “World’s Best Cup of Coffee.” Simple of not, Ferrell brings the humor alive on the screen in a way that is fun (and funny) for both kids and adults alike.
Other than cartoon-type trips, falls and scuffles, there is no violence to speak of in this film. There is no gore, and the closest we get to bloodshed is the finger-prick Buddy undergoes to have a DNA test in the doctor’s office. There is also no home for sexual content in this movie. Buddy meets his love interest Jovie, an elf at the department store Gimbel’s where Buddy accidentally lands a job. We see one innocent kiss in the movie — and you can count on hearing no overt sexual innuendo.
Now, don’t get me wrong, no movie is perfect. This one, despite its “feel-good” qualities does ask you to stretch the outer boundaries of your imagination a bit. Truly, what is the likelihood that an elf, who ultimately ends up saving Christmas could safely make his way to the Bi Apple on an iceberg? Is it possible for a human to survive on a diet of confections and still look not-so-bad in green tights? Favreau asks you to take a leap of faith to believe that Walter’s wife (Mary Steenburgen) would so gladly take in her husband’s illegitimate son and treat him as her own. But, for this movie, it seems to work, if for no other reason than you want it to.
Ferrell and Favreau prove that you don’t need curse words or suggestive dialogue to entertain and transport your audience for an hour and a half. It can be done with a kind-hearted storyline and a sincere desire to recapture the wonderment you felt as a child during the Christmas season. Amidst the other epic tales on the big screen this year, those that depict war or struggles between good and evil or even those that strive to thrill rated-R audiences, Elf will assuredly be the bright, shining star. You can take your family to this movie and walk away smiling and feeling good about everything — I did.
-
Archives
- October 2019 (3)
- May 2018 (2)
- October 2017 (2)
- November 2016 (5)
- October 2016 (1)
- September 2016 (8)
- August 2016 (6)
- July 2016 (1)
- June 2016 (5)
- May 2016 (8)
- April 2016 (14)
- March 2016 (2)
-
Categories
-
RSS
Entries RSS
Comments RSS